Skip to content

Google Wants to Run Your Ads. Should You Let It?

As Google hands more advertising decisions to AI, marketers need to decide which ones they’re comfortable giving up.

Travis MacDougall
Travis MacDougall Senior Director, Digital Performance

 

 

TL;DR

Google is automating more of the decisions that once defined PPC management. From matching ads to searches and generating copy to selecting landing pages and optimizing bids, AI is increasingly responsible for how advertising budgets are spent.

And much of this automation works remarkably well.

But there’s an important distinction between optimizing advertising performance and understanding what makes advertising valuable to a business.

The future of PPC management isn’t about fighting automation. It’s about knowing what to automate, what to question and which decisions should remain firmly in human hands.

Google Would Like to Take a Few Things Off Your Plate

Google has an offer for advertisers.

Stop worrying so much about the details. Let AI handle the keywords, the bids, the creative variations and the landing pages. Tell Google what you’re trying to achieve, and its technology will figure out how to get you there.

Sounds pretty good, actually.

Particularly if you’ve ever spent an afternoon adjusting bids, reviewing search terms or trying to understand why a perfectly reasonable campaign has suddenly decided to stop performing.

And Google isn’t just suggesting this direction. It’s actively moving advertisers toward it.

In April 2026, Google announced that its AI Max for Search campaigns was moving out of beta, along with plans to transition legacy advertising features into its AI-powered system.

The automatic transition of Dynamic Search Ads is now scheduled to begin in February 2027.

With AI Max, Google can expand beyond an advertiser’s existing keywords, generate and customize ad copy, and select landing pages based on what it determines to be relevant to a user’s search.

Google reports that advertisers using the full AI Max feature suite achieve, on average, 7% more conversions or conversion value at a similar cost per acquisition or return on ad spend than those using search term matching alone.

That’s a compelling proposition.

But it also raises an interesting question.

When the company selling you advertising is increasingly making the decisions about how to spend your advertising budget, who’s really in control?

First, Let’s Give Automation Some Credit

There’s a temptation to approach every new advertising automation feature with suspicion.

Particularly if you’ve spent years developing the expertise required to manage campaigns manually.

But let’s be fair.

Google’s AI has access to signals, processing power and real-time information that no human PPC specialist could reasonably replicate.

It can evaluate combinations of search intent, audience behaviour, device, location, timing and historical performance at extraordinary speed.

It can identify search opportunities that weren’t captured by existing keyword lists.

It can adjust bids in real time.

It can test combinations of messaging and direct users to potentially more relevant landing pages.

And it can do all of this across thousands of auctions while the rest of us are still trying to decide what to have for lunch.

That’s genuinely useful.

The technology can remove an enormous amount of repetitive work and help marketers discover opportunities they might otherwise miss.

In fact, resisting automation simply because it replaces a task someone used to perform manually isn’t much of a strategy.

The more interesting question is what happens when we confuse the ability to optimize a campaign with the ability to understand a business.

Because those are not the same thing.

Google Knows How to Optimize for Conversions. Does It Know Which Conversions Matter?

Imagine you’re a B2B company selling a complex service.

Your Google Ads account is configured to generate leads.

AI begins identifying opportunities, adjusting bids and finding audiences more likely to complete a form.

Your cost per lead decreases.

Conversions increase.

Your dashboard looks fantastic.

There’s just one problem.

Sales doesn’t want most of the leads.

They’re students researching the industry. Small businesses that can’t afford the service. People looking for something vaguely related but not actually relevant.

From Google’s perspective, the campaign may be doing exactly what it was instructed to do.

It’s generating leads efficiently.

But from the business’s perspective, it’s spending money on prospects who were never going to become customers.

The algorithm hasn’t necessarily failed.

It’s succeeding against an incomplete definition of success.

And that’s where things get interesting.

Automation is exceptionally good at optimizing toward the signals it’s given.

But the quality of those signals depends on the decisions marketers make before the system starts learning.

Which actions count as conversions?

How much is a qualified lead worth?

Which customers are genuinely profitable?

What happens after someone submits a form?

Are we trying to capture existing demand or create incremental growth?

These questions aren’t technical details.

They’re business decisions.

And if they’re answered poorly, automation can become extraordinarily efficient at producing the wrong outcomes.

There’s a Difference Between Platform Performance and Business Performance

Google’s advertising tools are designed to help advertisers achieve the objectives they configure.

But those objectives are often proxies for business growth.

A conversion isn’t necessarily a customer.

A customer isn’t necessarily a profitable customer.

And a profitable conversion doesn’t necessarily mean the advertising created demand that wouldn’t have existed otherwise.

Consider branded search.

Someone hears about your company through a colleague, remembers seeing a campaign, then searches for your brand by name.

They click your paid search ad and make a purchase.

The campaign records a conversion.

Useful? Absolutely.

But did the paid ad create the demand, or did it capture demand that already existed?

That’s a different question.

And it’s one that matters when deciding where to invest the next dollar.

The point isn’t that platform reporting is misleading or irrelevant.

It’s that platform reporting only tells part of the story.

It can describe what happened within the advertising system.

Understanding whether that activity contributed to meaningful business growth often requires looking beyond it.

That’s why marketers still need to connect platform data with CRM information, sales outcomes, customer value and, where appropriate, incrementality testing.

Otherwise, it’s entirely possible to build a beautifully optimized campaign that looks more successful than the business feels.

The JK Take: The Future of PPC Expertise Isn’t About Pulling Levers. It’s About Knowing Which Levers Should Never Be Handed Over.

For years, PPC management services were often associated with technical expertise.

Keyword research. Bid adjustments. Match types. Campaign structures. Negative keywords. Testing. Optimization.

Those skills still matter.

But as the platforms automate more of the mechanics, the value of PPC expertise needs to evolve.

The question is no longer simply, “How do we make this campaign perform better?”

It’s also, “Are we asking this campaign to accomplish the right thing?”

That’s a much more strategic responsibility.

It means understanding the business model, the audience, the economics of acquisition and the role paid search plays within the broader marketing strategy.

It means recognizing when an apparent performance improvement doesn’t translate into business value.

It means knowing when to trust the machine, when to investigate its decisions and when to change the inputs altogether.

And importantly, it means understanding that the platform’s recommendations are not the same thing as an independent growth strategy.

Google has every reason to develop tools that make advertising more effective and easier to manage.

Advertisers have every reason to take advantage of them.

But the responsibility for deciding what success means should remain with the business investing the money.

So, Which Decisions Should You Hand Over to AI?

The answer isn’t to maintain manual control over everything.

It’s to separate decisions that benefit from automation from those that require business context.

Let AI Handle the Complexity Humans Can’t Reasonably Manage

Real-time bid optimization, large-scale pattern recognition and testing combinations of advertising assets are natural opportunities for automation.

These are tasks where technology can process more information, faster, than a human team.

Provided the system has accurate conversion data and clear performance objectives, there’s significant value in allowing it to optimize within defined parameters.

Keep Business Objectives and Economics in Human Hands

AI can optimize toward a target cost per acquisition.

But someone needs to determine whether that target actually makes financial sense.

That requires understanding margins, lifetime customer value, sales capacity, retention and broader growth priorities.

A campaign that generates inexpensive leads may be less valuable than one that produces fewer, higher-quality opportunities.

The algorithm needs to know the difference.

Keep Brand Judgment in the Process

AI Max can generate advertising copy and select landing pages using information from your website and existing campaign assets.

That can improve relevance at scale.

But relevance isn’t the only consideration.

A message can be technically accurate while misrepresenting the brand’s positioning.

It can attract attention from an audience you don’t want.

It can emphasize an offer that doesn’t align with your commercial priorities.

Or it can send users to a page that isn’t appropriate for the decision they’re trying to make.

Google provides controls for text customization, brand terms, locations and URLs, along with reporting that helps advertisers evaluate AI-generated combinations.

The important thing is to use them.

Automation should expand execution possibilities without giving up responsibility for how the brand shows up.

Keep Budget Strategy Separate From Bid Optimization

AI can help determine how aggressively to bid within a campaign.

But deciding how much to invest in paid search in the first place is a different question.

Should additional budget go toward capturing existing demand?

Would it create more value in building awareness?

Are there audience segments, products or geographies that deserve greater investment?

Is the business becoming too dependent on paid acquisition?

Those choices require a view of the entire marketing ecosystem.

No single advertising platform can make them independently of the business’s priorities.

How to Prepare Your PPC Strategy for More Automation

With Google’s transition toward AI Max continuing into 2027, now is a useful time to examine how your campaigns are configured and measured.

Not because automation is inherently risky.

Because the more responsibility you delegate, the more important your instructions become.

Here are five places to start.

1. Audit What Your Campaigns Are Actually Optimizing For

Review your conversion actions.

Are you measuring activities that reliably indicate business value, or simply activities that are easy to track?

Where possible, connect advertising performance to qualified leads, sales outcomes and customer value.

A more accurate definition of success gives automated bidding a better objective to pursue.

2. Review Your AI Max Settings and Controls

Understand which features are enabled and what they allow Google to do.

Review search term matching, text customization, final URL expansion and any applicable brand or location settings.

Check where advertisements may appear, what messaging can be generated and which pages can be used as destinations.

Don’t assume automation means control is unavailable.

Google has introduced more tools to help advertisers guide AI Max, but those controls only help if someone understands and uses them.

3. Test Automation Against Business Outcomes

Don’t evaluate an automated feature solely on whether reported conversions increase.

Consider lead quality, customer acquisition cost, revenue contribution and other measures relevant to your business.

Where possible, use controlled experiments to understand whether a new feature creates additional value.

The goal isn’t to prove AI works or doesn’t work.

It’s to discover where it works best for your business.

4. Decide Where Human Review Is Non-Negotiable

Not every automated decision requires approval.

But some deserve explicit oversight.

For example:

    • Changes to conversion goals and assigned values
    • Significant shifts in budget allocation
    • Brand-sensitive advertising claims
    • Expansion into new audiences or search contexts
    • Changes that affect profitability or customer quality

Define these responsibilities before something goes wrong.

5. Give Your PPC Team a Bigger Job

If your PPC specialists are spending less time manually adjusting campaigns, that should create capacity for more valuable work.

Deeper audience analysis.

More thoughtful experimentation.

Improving landing page experiences.

Understanding customer economics.

Evaluating performance across channels.

Connecting advertising outcomes to business growth.

The opportunity isn’t simply to do PPC management faster.

It’s to make PPC management more useful.

Does Your Business Still Need PPC Management Services?

It’s a fair question.

If Google can automate bidding, targeting, creative combinations and much of the day-to-day optimization, why pay someone to manage it?

The answer depends on what you’re paying them to do.

If the value of a PPC management agency is limited to performing tasks the platform can now automate, that value is becoming harder to defend.

But if the agency helps you make better investment decisions, improve the quality of your data, design meaningful experiments, challenge misleading performance signals and connect paid media to business outcomes, that’s a different proposition.

In fact, as advertising platforms become more automated, independent expertise may become more valuable.

Not because humans need to second-guess every decision the machine makes.

But because businesses need someone who is accountable for more than the platform’s performance metrics.

Someone who understands why the company is advertising in the first place.

The Best PPC Strategy Isn’t Human or AI. It’s Both.

Google is going to keep automating advertising.

And frankly, that’s probably a good thing.

There’s no particular virtue in spending hours manually performing work that technology can do better.

But automation changes the nature of expertise.

The value shifts away from operating the machinery and toward knowing what the machinery should be doing.

That means better objectives. Better data. Better judgment. Better questions.

And the confidence to challenge impressive-looking results when they don’t translate into meaningful growth.

So, should you let Google run your ads?

In many respects, yes.

Just don’t let Google decide what your business should be trying to achieve.

 

Humanology Moment

Trusting a machine to optimize your campaigns is one thing.
Trusting it to understand your business is another.

AI can identify patterns in customer behaviour, adjust bids and pursue conversion goals with extraordinary precision.

But it doesn’t sit in your sales meetings. It doesn’t hear the frustration behind a pipeline full of unqualified leads. It doesn’t understand why your most profitable customer isn’t necessarily your easiest customer to acquire.

Leadership Takeaways

  • Google’s AI Max transition is accelerating the automation of search advertising.
  • Automation can improve campaign efficiency, but better platform metrics don’t always translate into better business outcomes.
  • Conversion quality, profitability and incrementality matter more than conversion volume alone.
  • Marketers should automate technical optimization while retaining ownership of business objectives, brand decisions and budget strategy.
  • PPC expertise is shifting from manual campaign management toward measurement, experimentation and strategic oversight.
  • The goal isn’t to control every decision AI makes. It’s to give AI better decisions to optimize against.

Never miss another blog post

Want to sign up for updates, announcements, offers and promotions from Jan Kelley? Simply fill in the form below and we’ll keep you up to date. You may later withdraw your consent at any time. Check out our Privacy Policy.

Thank you.

We've received your message and will be in touch as soon as possible.

Close